Saturday, October 3, 2015

Beauty in Brokeness


Beauty in Brokenness

October 4 / 2015                  World Wide Communion Sunday

A few years ago a woman in a congregation I was serving contacted me to get together to talk about some stuff she had going on in her life.   Although she was a member of the congregation I had never met her as she did not attend worship.  She came to my office, spent some time doing idle chit-chat – and then with much hesitation she began to tell me about how her marriage was falling apart.  She had discovered that her husband had been having an affair and she did not know whether the marriage was going to survive this betrayal.  As we talked, and shared, it became clearer and clearer that she was not seeking my advice or looking to me for counselling, or even wanting to enter into a pastoral care relationship – she came to see me because she was scared, scared that if her marriage ended in divorce that God would be mad at her.  She came seeking reassurance from the minister that God would not hate her because her marriage was falling apart.  I find this quite disturbing that this woman who was suffering and sad and barely holding it together and in her sorrow and pain had to question whether or not she was destroying her relationship to God because her relationship to her husband was falling apart.  It seems to me that when we read texts such as the one we just heard from Mark – for people living a broken relationship, it is hard to feel supported by the story we just heard. 

Let’s look at this from another perspective – when we read this text we often skip right to what Jesus is saying about marriage, commitment and relationship.  But this story is set in a context – that is to say – this story is happening in the midst of the whole of Jesus story – and this story happens in the middle of the story. Jesus has been teaching and preaching and healing and exorcising demons for a couple of years now and he has begun to make an impression on those around him.  This story continues on from last week, they have left the house in Capernaum and have moved on to Judea, and when they stopped Jesus was one again surrounded with crowds of people who have come to see what is going on.  Jesus popularity is growing but also he is making enemies.  Those who particularly do not like what he has to say and what he is doing are the religious authorities.  The Pharisees are taking exception to what Jesus saying and they using every opportunity to challenge what he is say – to question the authority from which Jesus speaks.  They are seeking to make Jesus look foolish, to make him look like he doesn’t know what he is talking about so that he will loose his popularity and go back to obscurity.  And if Jesus is made to look foolish than those who are listening may begin to doubt what he is saying to. 

This text, though, is not so much about what Jesus says about divorce as it is about how Jesus is challenged by the Pharisees as they try to trick him into saying something they can call him out on – they are trying to make his say something that will alienate from the people who are listening to him in this moment.  And so they challenge him about the law – and the law they hold up as a challenge is the divorce law. 

David Lose writes:  This isn’t a casual – …, conversation about love, marriage, and divorce. It’s a test. Moreover, it’s not even a test about divorce, but about the law.   “Some Pharisees came and to test him they asked, is it lawful”  There were, you see, several competing schools of thought about the legality of divorce. Not so much about whether divorce was legal – everyone agreed upon that –that it was legal - but under what circumstances, that was the challenging question. And with this question/test, the Pharisees are trying to pin Jesus down, trying to label him, trying to draw him out and perhaps entrap him so that they know better how to deal with him.” [1]

The Pharisee’s asked is it lawful, not – ‘what do you think about divorce’ or ‘what do you believe God wants people to do when their marriages is no longer working’, or not ‘give us your opinion Jesus on the state of married life in Judea two millennium ago’ - what the Pharisees are asking Jesus to do is to interpret the law – But as we know when Jesus is challenged he rarely ever answers the challenging question in the way that is expected of him – tell us about the law Jesus and so Jesus starts to talk about relationships

I think it is really important that we listen to what Jesus has to say next– how many of us here in this places lives have been impacted by divorce – either ourselves living in a marriage breakdown – or our parents – or our children, or others in our families – I bet that everyone here has had someone they love live through a divorce…we know how painful they are, how much people suffer – how it hurts to live in a broken relationships…we know…and we also know that this text has been used to justify bad marriages staying together – to judge people who have made the divorce choice – so please be careful how you hear the next words that Jesus says.

Jesus says what Moses said – Moses who was human, Moses the one that God gave the law to –on the stone tablets – and then he talks about God’s place in all of it – how we are all male and female both part of the creation – and so partnerships with another are entered into on equal footing with both partners on the same ground, no one better than the other, neither one with advantages over the other.  Jesus was talking about healthy relationships with each other.

David Lose again:  Jesus isn’t speaking to individuals, you see, he’s making a statement about the kind of community we will be. In fact, he’s inviting us to imagine communities centered in and on real relationships; relationships, that is, founded on love and mutual dependence, fostered by respect and dignity, and pursued for the sake of the health of the community and the protection of the vulnerable…

This whole passage, I think, is about community. But it’s not the kind of community we’ve been trained to seek. It’s not, that is, a community of the strong, or the wealthy, or the powerful, or the independent. Rather, this is a community of the broken, of the vulnerable, of those at risk. It’s a community, in other words, of those who know their need and seek to be in relationship with each other because they have learned that by being in honest and open relationship with each other they are in relationship with God, the very one who created them for each other in the first place….
When we look at this passage this way, …, not so much as instructions about divorce but instead as an invitation to see our communities as those places where God’s work to heal and restore the whole creation is ongoing, not by taking away all our problems but surrounding us with people who understand, and care, and help us to discover together our potential to reach out to others in love and compassion  We are communities of the broken, but we are those broken whom God loves and is healing and, indeed, using to make all things new?[2]
Which is what we are about to do and experience when we move in the next few minutes to the table – the table that is spread in our midst the holds for us this community of faith - the bread of Christ and the cup of salvation – we come to this table this morning as individuals who have been broken, people who have struggled, some who are doubting, some strong in faith, some who are despairing others who sing with joy – but all of us children of God
It is only in recognizing our brokenness do we come to the table in truth – it is only when we realize that this table is about accepting our brokenness, and seeing the beauty.  This table that holds the Lord’s supper is our table of blessing, our table of wholeness where the lost become found and the weak become strong, and the last is first and a little child belongs to the kingdom.


This table is a place of restoration.  This communion an opportunity for the kingdom to come into this place if only for just a moment.  This meal is an invitation for our community to be place where God’s work is done.  This table offer’s the invitation to see our communities as those places where God’s work to heal and restore the whole creation is ongoing, not by taking away all our problems but surrounding us with people who understand, and care, (that would be your neighbour sitting in the pews beside you right now) the ones that help us to discover together our potential to reach out to others in love and compassion.  We are communities of the broken, but we are those broken whom God loves and is healing and, indeed, using to make all things new.  Let us share this feast of healing as a community of the beautiful broken God’s beloved people.  Amen. 





[1] David Lose:  In the Meantime  http://www.davidlose.net/2015/09/pentecost-19-b-communities-of-the-broken-and-blessed/
[2] ibid.

No comments:

Post a Comment